4 Lawyer Habits You Need to Break in an Authoritarian Momen

When Minneapolis union workers gathered to build neighborhood defense networks against escalating ICE raids in 2025, undercover federal agents slipped into the back rows to covertly surveil the room. Weeks later, prosecutors hit the unions with subpoenas alleging an anti-government conspiracy, combing bank records—only to find routine line items for member dues, strike supplies, and retiree pensions.

A year later in Texas, an elementary school aide was charged with providing material support to “terrorists” and handed a 30-year prison sentence for moving and supposedly concealing a box of political zines. The aide was one of several people who received harsh sentences for their involvement in a protest outside of the Prairieland immigrant detention facility–despite the fact that he was miles away when the confrontation occurred. 

These are not isolated cases. They are deliberate authoritarian tactics. And they are just two of a growing number of examples of the authoritarian regime weaponizing powers of the state to attack its perceived political opponents and those who dissent. 

Authoritarians advance by capturing the machineries of power—administrative agencies, the executive branch, and the court system itself—to legitimize and normalize repression in the public eye. 

The good news is that we, as lawyers, have a unique role and skillset that can be leveraged to protect civil society: organizing groups, unions, faith-based organizations, and the countless other spaces that allow everyday people to organize and hold those in power accountable. Many of us are ready to take the step away from neutrality and move into action, but this authoritarian moment will require us to go beyond the traditional legal approaches. Why? Because we are in a political moment that no longer abides by the rule of law as we knew it. 

By adjusting our perspective, we can focus our efforts and build a more resilient legal sector that serves social movements. 

This moment of authoritarian violence requires lawyers to meet organizers and social movements  where they are at. We must build a movement lawyering ethos to effectively confront the challenges ahead and keep social movements above ground.

To help us get started in this new approach, Movement Law Lab has identified a few common lawyerly habits we must break and the new practices we must build in their place.

Habit 1: Over-Caution That Chills Organizing 

Legal training teaches lawyers to identify, explain, and recommend avoiding risks. This tendency is understandable; we have a duty to protect our clients, and in some contexts, an abundance of caution can be appropriate. But in moments of rising authoritarianism, too much risk aversion can function as a tool of authoritarianism, depressing much-needed resistance tactics before they can get off the ground. Here we should consider building courageous counsel.

For example, when an organizer asks whether a particular action is safe and a lawyer responds with every worst-case scenario—every possible charge, every procedural risk, every thing that could go wrong—without providing the likelihood of any of these scenarios, whether those outcomes have rarely happened or have happened in wildly different contexts. The effect, intended or not, is often to discourage the action.

Courageous counsel looks completely different in practice. We saw this in Chicago when movement lawyers supported community members confronting escalating ICE violence. Instead of telling organizers not to act because of the risks,  lawyers stepped in with “Know Your Risks” workshops. This gave residents and organizers clear, honest legal information so they could make their own informed decisions on their own terms.

This approach requires trusting that organizers are skilled enough to weigh their options and are asking for information–not permission or dissuasion–to make difficult decisions. It also requires lawyers to be the person who supports others in acting bravely, not the person who talks them out of something they feel is imperative to supporting their communities to respond to authoritarian violence.

It’s time to stop talking people out of taking risks and start informing them of considerations so they can take the next step in their organizing with information they need.

Habit 2: Making Every Problem an Individual Case

Lawyers are trained to understand legal representation as a solo endeavor: find a client, assess their situation, develop a strategy, and proceed. One client, one case, one outcome. 

But authoritarianism is not an individual problem. It operates at scale, through systems, against communities. A wave of retaliatory arrests against dissidents is a pattern, not a single case. A series of arrests at the same intersection during the same protest is not a collection of unrelated criminal matters, it’s a tactic to crush organizing. Treating cases like this as though they stand alone—routing each person into their own isolated legal process—drains collective resources, fragments organizing, and misses the systemic picture entirely.

We can’t let authoritarians undermine our movements with divide and conquer tactics. This moment requires lawyers to see the big picture, consider both individual and collective interests, coordinate across specialties, and be ready to flank mass organizing moments.

Authoritarianism won't be defeated by a single case. We need to collectivize our efforts and support social movements writ large.

Habit 3: Imagining Lawyers as the Saviors

The image of the lawyer as the person who rides in, files the motion, and saves the day is embedded in legal and pop culture. It’s engrained in our training, in the stories we tell, in the metrics we use to measure success. It can make us show up to movement spaces as though our arrival is the point. It can make us center our expertise over the community's existing analysis and strategy. 

But positioning ourselves as the “saviors” can make this moment more perilous. It can lead us to take up space that belongs to the people — organizers, directly impacted community members, grassroots leaders– who were doing the work long before we arrived and will be there long after. And if we position ourselves as the protagonists, we risk hindering relationships with the people who make up the social movements we want to support.

Lawyering in times of authoritarianism requires showing up with humility, listening before offering, and putting skills in service of strategies that communities are already building. 

The goal is not to lead the movement; it is to use the skill set we have to ensure they stay above ground so they can lead civil society into mass resistance of authoritarianism. 

Habit 4: Staying in Our Lane When the Road Has Changed

Immigration law is not housing law. Housing law is not labor law. We are trained to specialize, to stay within our competencies and legal comfort zones. 

But authoritarian repression is deliberately cross-sectoral. It targets workers through immigration enforcement, organizers through criminal prosecution, and some communities through coordinated, overlapping systems of pressure. Authoritarians also invent new strategies, like domestic terrorist designations, that don’t clearly fall in any lawyer’s wheelhouse. When lawyers remain siloed—each in their own issue area, filing their own motions, attending their own convenings—the sector remains overwhelmed, isolated and unable to meet the moment.

Staying in your lane isn't a virtue when the road has changed. Lawyers need to stretch themselves to be able to more effectively meet authoritarian tactics that lack obvious answers. We need build connections with lawyers with different practice areas so  we can refer effectively when something falls outside of our lanes, and strategize together when we need to. And we need to contribute to  larger coordinated responses rather than parallel ones.

For example, when federal agents launched “Operation Metro Surge” across Minnesota, arresting workers at daycares and neighborhoods, immigration legal aid groups were instantly overwhelmed. People were snatched off the street and transferred out of state within hours, not days. Deportation flights left the city daily. Entire communities were terrorized. But lawyers and communities didn’t give up – they got organized. When immigrant families and legal organizations put out the call, hundreds of Minnesota attorneys who had never touched immigration law refused to stay in their lanes. Complex civil litigators, data privacy specialists, and family law attorneys pooled templates, triaged intake, and quickly filed emergency habeas corpus petitions in federal court. 

By stepping outside their narrow specialties, non-immigration litigators halted out-of-state transfers and secured the release of people unlawfully detained. Don’t stay in your lane. Connect with lawyers from a variety of fields to protect people who could use your skills, time, and knowledge. 

Conclusion 

No lawyer builds a movement alone, and no two communities face the exact same terrain. You don’t need to master every issue overnight or launch a new coalition by next week.

Start with one deliberate shift. Move out of your silo and into real relationship with organizers. Trade the kind of caution that chills action for counsel that helps people move. Step back from the heroic solo case and build toward coordinated, collective defense.

Lawyers aren't the saviors of social movements, but we do have a distinct role in flanking the movements that serve as the base for a robust civil society. Authoritarians move to capture the legal system early because they understand its ability to be both a weapon and a shield. To meet this moment, we must also wield it with the same level of ferocity in support of social movements fighting for democracy.

It won't feel like enough at first. Do it anyway. The muscle will build from there.

Previous
Previous

Block and Build: Lessons on Democracy and Authoritarianism from South Africa’s Movement Lawyers

Next
Next

The midterms are the next phase of the authoritarian advance. Here’s how movement lawyers can fight back.